Why A Co-Parenting Christmas Isn’t Always The Best Choice

The holiday season is often a time filled with joy, warmth, and togetherness. But for divorced parents, it can also bring a unique set of challenges. Especially if it’s your first Christmas since splitting! A common dilemma I see for my coaching clients is deciding whether to spend Christmas together for the sake of the children. The idea of creating a harmonious holiday experience might seem appealing, but it also comes with potential emotional and psychological implications. In this blog post, I’ll list some pros and cons of spending Christmas with your ex and provide insights to help you make the best decision for your family.

The Pros of Spending Christmas Together

Consistency for the Children: The idea of spending Christmas together can provide a sense of continuity, stability, and comfort for your children. If they’re used to celebrating the holidays as a family, keeping this tradition alive can help them feel secure and loved. It can be comforting for kids to know that, despite the divorce, both parents are still present and invested in their happiness.
Modelling Cooperation: By spending the holidays together, you demonstrate to your children that you can put differences aside and work together for their benefit. And that you are still tied together as a family. This sets a powerful example of cooperation and maturity, showing them that conflict doesn’t have to result in bitterness or ongoing animosity.
Creating Positive Memories: Christmas is about creating joyful and lasting memories. By celebrating together, you give your children happy recollections of their holiday season. These shared moments can be invaluable in maintaining a strong family bond, even if the family structure has changed.
Reducing Stress for the Kids: Dividing time between two households can be stressful for children, especially during the holiday season. Especially when emotions are high. By spending the day together, you eliminate the need for them to choose between parents or rush from one house to another, allowing them to relax and enjoy the festivities.

The Cons of Spending Christmas Together

Emotional Tension: Even with the best intentions, unresolved feelings or conflicts can surface when spending time with an ex. Add the stress of being around each other, the addition of alcohol, and past memories. The pressure to present a united front might also lead to tension and arguments, which can be confusing and distressing for the children. If the atmosphere isn’t genuinely positive, the experience can backfire, creating more anxiety than joy.
Mixed Messages: Spending Christmas together might send mixed signals to the children about the status of your relationship. They may misinterpret your actions as a sign that reconciliation is possible. This can lead to confusion and false hope. It’s important to ensure that your actions align with the reality of your situation to avoid emotional upheaval.
Impact on Personal Healing: Being around your ex, especially during significant events like Christmas, can disrupt your healing process. It might bring up painful memories, make it harder to move on, or delay the process of redefining yourself outside of the relationship. Prioritising your emotional well-being is crucial for your long-term happiness and ability to parent effectively.
New Relationships: If either parent is in a new relationship, spending Christmas together might cause discomfort, awkwardness, or jealousy. This could lead to additional tension and hurt feelings, complicating co-parenting dynamics and making it harder to maintain healthy boundaries.

Making the Decision: What’s Best for Your Family?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to whether or not you should spend Christmas with your ex. But here are some considerations to help you make the right choice for your family:

Assess Your Relationship: Honestly evaluate your relationship with your ex. Can you both put aside past differences and focus on the children without conflict? If there’s ongoing tension, it might be best to celebrate separately to maintain a peaceful environment.
Consider the Children’s Needs: Talk to your children about their feelings and preferences. While younger kids might benefit from a united front, older children may understand the reality of the situation and prefer a peaceful, divided celebration.
Set Clear Boundaries: If you decide to spend Christmas together, establish clear boundaries and expectations. Plan the day together, discuss any potential issues in advance, and agree on how to handle them. This preparation can help minimise conflict and ensure a smooth celebration.
Alternative Solutions: If spending the entire day together feels too challenging, consider alternative ways to share the day. You might, for example, choose to have a joint breakfast or open presents together in the morning, then spend the rest of the day separately. This allows for some family time without the pressure of a full day.
Communicate with New Partners: If new partners are involved, have an open conversation about your holiday plans. Reassure them of their place in your life and involve them in other holiday traditions. Balancing these relationships with respect and honesty will help prevent feelings of exclusion or resentment.

The decision to spend Christmas with your ex is a very personal one. Every situation is unique. It’s important to do what feels right for you and your family. Also remember that just because you do it one way this year, doesn’t mean you have to do it that way next year. Or that it needs to stay that way.

Ultimately, your decision should prioritise the emotional well-being of both the children and yourself. If celebrating together creates a peaceful and joyful experience, it can be a wonderful way to show your children that love and cooperation transcend divorce. However, if it leads to tension or confusion, it’s perfectly acceptable to create separate but equally meaningful traditions. Remember, the goal is to create a positive and loving environment where everyone feels safe, respected, and valued. No matter whether you celebrate together, or not.

P.S. DID YOU KNOW?

Thrive Tribe – the global membership experience for single mothers – will be opening again very soon! Join the waitlist here.

PLUS You can book one-on-one coaching with Julia Hasche from wherever you are in the world!

Do you need clarity on whether you should leave your partner or not?
Have you just parted ways with your partner, and feeling lost?
Have you been single for a little while now and need assistance with getting your life back on track and feeling empowered?

Click HERE to read about coaching and to hear from some others who have gone through coaching programs with Julia, and book in here for your 30-minute complimentary Clarity Call.

The purpose of the Clarity Call is:

For me to get to know you and understand an overview of your current situation and where you are at.
For us to establish what you need assistance with to move forward.
To see if we are both comfortable working together.